Fixed or tracker mortgage: how to decide

9 November 2026

A couple reviewing mortgage paperwork and a laptop at the kitchen table

The Bank of England raised Bank Rate from 3.75% to 4% on 5 November 2026, the first rise in over three years. If you're remortgaging in the next few months, that single number sits at the centre of the one decision that matters most: fixed or tracker. This guide walks through what each option actually does to your payment, a worked comparison with real arithmetic, and a short checklist to work through this week — not a forecast of where rates go next, because nobody, including the Bank itself, can tell you that with certainty.

What "fixed" and "tracker" actually mean

A fixed-rate mortgage locks your interest rate for an agreed period, usually two, five or sometimes ten years. Whatever Bank Rate does in that time, your monthly payment doesn't move. A tracker mortgage moves automatically with Bank Rate, at a margin the lender sets when you take the deal out — for example "Bank Rate plus 0.75%". When Bank Rate rose on 5 November, every tracker borrower's rate rose with it that same month, with no letter, no decision and no opt-out. A third option sits in the background whether you choose it or not: the standard variable rate (SVR), which is what you fall onto automatically if a fixed or tracker deal ends and you haven't arranged a new one. SVRs currently run anywhere from about 4.9% to 6.9% depending on lender, and the lender can change it whenever it chooses, not only when Bank Rate moves — it is almost always the most expensive of the three, which is the main reason to act before a deal ends rather than after.

The real trade-off: certainty, and what it costs

A fix is insurance against future rate rises. You pay for that certainty whether or not the rise ever happens — and if Bank Rate falls instead, you're stuck paying more than a tracker borrower would. A tracker is the opposite bet: it's usually priced a little cheaper than the equivalent fix today, by around 0.75 to 1 percentage point on current deals, because you're accepting the risk the fixed-rate lender would otherwise have priced in. Neither is objectively "right" — it's a question of which kind of surprise you can tolerate less: a payment that's fixed but might turn out higher than it needed to be, or a payment that could rise further with no warning.

Worked example: a £200,000 balance, 25 years remaining

Illustrative figures, calculated against this week's typical published rates. Say you're remortgaging £200,000 with 25 years left on the term, choosing between a two-year fix at a typical current rate of 4.9%, and a tracker priced at Bank Rate plus 0.75% — 4.75% today.

  • The fix: £1,157.56 a month, fixed for two years regardless of what Bank Rate does.
  • The tracker today: £1,140.23 a month — £17.32 a month cheaper, £207.87 a year cheaper than the fix, for as long as Bank Rate stays where it is.
  • If Bank Rate rises a further 0.5 percentage points over the two years (to 4.5%, taking the tracker to 5.25%): the tracker becomes £1,198.50 a month — £40.94 a month, about £491 a year, more expensive than the fix would have been.
  • If Bank Rate instead falls 0.5 percentage points (to 3.5%, taking the tracker to 4.25%): the tracker stays at £1,083.48 a month — £74.08 a month, about £889 a year, cheaper than the fix.

On this size of balance and term, each 0.25 percentage point move in Bank Rate is worth roughly £29 a month either way. The fix removes that swing entirely for two years; the tracker keeps you exposed to it in both directions.

Five questions that actually decide this

Rather than guessing where Bank Rate goes next, work through what you already know about your own situation:

  1. Could your budget absorb a few more 0.25-point rises? Using the £29-a-month-per-0.25-point rule of thumb above, work out what two or three further rises would cost you on a tracker, and check that figure against what's actually spare in your budget each month.
  2. How long are you likely to keep this mortgage? If you expect to move, remortgage again, or clear a large chunk of the balance within two years, a tracker's lower early-exit cost and lower starting rate matter more, because you're less exposed to a long run of rises.
  3. What's the early repayment charge (ERC) on each option? Fixed deals usually carry a bigger ERC than trackers if you need to leave early — check your mortgage offer document for the exact percentage before assuming either is flexible.
  4. How soon does your current deal end? If it's within the next six months, start comparing now rather than waiting for the renewal letter — many lenders let you reserve a new rate up to six months ahead and switch to a cheaper one if rates fall before completion.
  5. Does a whole-of-market comparison change the answer? The rates above are typical, not universal — a mortgage broker can check deals across the market rather than just your existing lender's range, and mortgage advice is a regulated activity, so confirm any adviser you use is on the FCA Register.

What to do this week

  1. Find your current deal's end date and, if it's inside six months, start comparing now.
  2. Run the £29-per-0.25-point rule against your own balance and budget to see how much headroom you actually have on a tracker.
  3. Pull your mortgage offer document and check the exact ERC percentages on any deal you're considering leaving.
  4. Get a whole-of-market comparison rather than relying only on your existing lender's own range — see our guide on when a mortgage broker is worth using.
  5. Use MoneyHelper's free mortgage calculators and guidance at moneyhelper.org.uk to sanity-check any numbers a lender or broker gives you — it's free, independent and doesn't sell mortgages.

This is general information, not personal financial advice. It doesn't recommend a specific lender, rate or product, and it isn't a forecast of where Bank Rate goes next. Mortgage advice is a regulated activity — for guidance tailored to your own numbers, use MoneyHelper's free mortgage guidance or gov.uk, or speak to a broker or adviser authorised by the FCA, checkable at register.fca.org.uk.

If your fix is ending and lenders have already started pushing rates up, our piece on the remortgage cliff walks through what that's cost borrowers coming off older deals. And if the mortgage side of the decision is sorted but you're wondering what this same rate move does to savings sitting in cash, our Bank Rate rise explainer covers that half separately, since the two don't move in step.

Common questions

What's the real difference between a fixed-rate and a tracker mortgage?

A fixed-rate mortgage charges the same interest rate for an agreed period, usually two or five years, whatever the Bank of England does to Bank Rate in that time — your monthly payment stays put. A tracker moves automatically with Bank Rate, usually at a fixed margin above it, so when Bank Rate rose from 3.75% to 4% on 5 November 2026, every tracker borrower's payment went up that same month with no decision to make. Fall off either deal without remortgaging and you land on your lender's standard variable rate (SVR), which is typically the most expensive of the three and can change whenever the lender chooses, not just when Bank Rate moves.

Is a tracker ever the better choice when rates might rise again?

Yes, for the right borrower. Trackers are usually priced a little below the equivalent fix — currently by around 0.75 to 1 percentage point — because you're taking on the risk the lender would otherwise price in. That suits someone who could comfortably absorb a few more rate rises, who may move, overpay heavily or remortgage again within a year or two anyway, or who simply believes rates are closer to their peak than their floor. It suits a tight household budget far less well, because a tracker has no ceiling and the next three Bank of England decisions are not yet known.

How long should I fix for — two years or five?

It depends on how far ahead you can see. A two-year fix gets you back to the market sooner, which matters if you expect your circumstances to change — a move, a pay rise, a plan to overpay the balance down — or if you think rates may fall and want to renegotiate again soon. A five-year fix usually carries a slightly higher rate but locks in five years of budget certainty and only two sets of remortgage fees across a decade instead of five. There's no universally correct length; it's a trade between paying a little more for longer certainty and paying a little less for the flexibility to change course sooner.

What happens if I need to get out of a fixed deal early?

You'll usually pay an early repayment charge (ERC), typically a percentage of the outstanding balance that steps down the longer you've held the deal — often around 5% in year one of a five-year fix, falling by roughly a point a year. On a £200,000 balance that can mean £10,000 or more in year one. Some lenders let you port a fixed rate to a new property without triggering the charge, or overpay up to 10% of the balance a year free of ERCs. Check your mortgage offer document for the exact percentages and any porting or overpayment allowance before you assume either option is available.

Is now, with Bank Rate at 4%, a good time to fix?

Nobody, including the Bank of England itself, can tell you where Bank Rate goes next — the committee that raised it to 4% on 5 November 2026 voted 8-1, which tells you even they aren't settled on the pace from here. What you can control is your own tolerance for a payment that might rise further on a tracker, against the certainty of a fixed payment priced on today's market. If a rate rise of even £30–£50 a month would strain your budget, that itself is useful information regardless of which way Bank Rate eventually moves.

Related reads

The remortgage cliff, explained — what rising rates mean if your fix is ending soon.
Bank Rate just rose to 4% — the same decision's effect on savings, worked through separately.
When to use a mortgage broker — whole-of-market comparison, how brokers are paid, and when going direct makes sense.
First-time buyer guide — deposits, affordability and the mortgage process from scratch.
How to build an emergency fund — the buffer that keeps a rate rise from becoming a crisis.
The big money decisions — buying a home, pensions, retirement and more.

Your Financial Freedom Score

The Financial Freedom Score is twenty-two questions across eight areas of your money and takes about seven minutes. Your result names the first thing to do.

Chat on WhatsApp
Financial Freedom ScoreTalk to a coach